20.5k unique visitors in the last 3 days

Indian Telco and Bank Ordered to Compensate SIM Swap Victim

All of the stolen money will now be refunded to the customer, more than three years after it was taken.

The Times of India reports that Indian telco BSNL and the Union Bank of India were ordered to pay legal fees and full compensation to a businessman whose money was stolen following a SIM swap.

Nagarathpet resident Ramesh Kumar has been using a mobile phone with a BSNL sim card for many years and had linked it to his account at Union Bank of India’s BVK Iyengar Road branch.

On September 22, 2015, Kumar checked his email to find that an unknown beneficiary had been added to his online bank account. By the time he could alert bank authorities about the breach, the fraudsters managed to transfer Rs 9,62,700 from his account. The sim card on his cellphone that was supposed to receive a one-time password (OTP) mysteriously remained de-activated all the while.

Kumar initially complained to the bank and to the local police. He then raised the matter with the Bangalore Urban 2nd Additional District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum. Progress was slow, with both the telco and the bank blaming each other for Kumar’s losses.

After 31 months the Forum concluded both businesses were at fault, with the telco responsible for issuing a duplicate SIM to the criminals, whilst the bank had allowed another customer to be added to Kumar’s account without warning him. The Forum ordered both firms to jointly refund the INR962,700 (USD13,700) that was stolen, plus INR10,000 (USD140) to cover Kumar’s legal expenses.

You can read the full Times of India story here.

Eric Priezkalns
Eric Priezkalnshttp://revenueprotect.com

During his career, Eric has been a Director of Risk Management for a national telco, the Chief Executive of the Risk & Assurance Group, a Chief Marketing Officer for a software business, a consultant, a public speaker and the publisher of Commsrisk since its launch in 2006. Look here for more about the history of Commsrisk and the role played by Eric.

The comms providers that Eric has worked for include Qatar Telecom, Cable & Wireless, T‑Mobile, Sky and Worldcom. In addition to his proficiency at speaking about the current scamdemic, Eric is also a qualified chartered accountant and a subject matter expert in consumer protection, enterprise risk management, fraud prevention, data integrity and billing accuracy. Eric was the lead author of Revenue Assurance: Expert Opinions for Communications Providers, published by CRC Press. He can be reached through the contact form on this website.

Related Articles

The Commsrisk Global Fraud Dashboard


Our Global Fraud Dashboard uses AI-powered search to collate, update and visualize data about scams and other network abuses from around the world. New charts are added each month. See it here.

Get Our Weekly Newsletter by Email